Jump to Navigation
California Board of Legal Specialization | Certified Specialist in Workers' Compensation Law by the State Bar of California Board of Legal Specialization
Law Offices of Vincent J. Scotto, III, Attorneys & Lawyers Employment & Workers Compensation, San Mateo, CA

Investigation finds few overturned workers' comp claim denials

By law, those who are eligible for workers' compensation benefits should receive them. A recent investigation by the NBC Bay Area news, however, reveals that this may not always be the case in California. Instead, many injured workers face denials of their claims for their treatment claims and very few denials overturned during the appeals process. 

The California workers' compensation system was reformed in 2013 as part of Senate Bill 863. As a result, applicants who have their treatment claims denied no longer appeal in front of a judge. Instead a private, for-profit corporation holds what are called Independent Medical Reviews (IMR) on behalf of the state.

This process has created an insurmountable obstacle for many injured workers seeking care. According to records, of the nearly 600,000 appeals for medical treatment between 2013 and 2015, the IMR doctors upheld the initial denial by the state. Proponents of this system see this as evidence that the correct decisions are being made earlier in the process, while others, including workers and their doctors, think the data shows that the process is flawed. 

Part of the controversy is related to the doctors selected to conduct the IMRs. The company awarded the contract to conduct these reviews, Maximus Federal Holdings, keeps the names of the doctors they employ confidential. Additionally, a significant percentage of those doctors are out of state.

Potentially most alarming is that the doctors never physically examine the injured workers. Instead, they are supplied with medical histories pertaining to the case and make determinations based on a set of standard guidelines. Decisions regarding the course of treatment are either a yes or a no - no alternative treatment options are suggested for denied claims.

Given the uphill battle many injured workers face, it may be in your best interests to obtain representation from a workers' comp attorney. With legal advice, counsel and advocacy, you may stand a better chance in obtaining the medical treatment you need for a work injury.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Contact Form

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

Contact Us

The Law Offices of Vincent J. Scotto, III
700 South Claremont Street
San Mateo, CA 94402

Telephone: 650-375-2301
Fax: 650-401-6129
San Mateo Law Office Map

Martinez Office
The Law Offices of Vincent J. Scotto, III
706 Ferry Street Martinez, CA 94553

Telephone: 925-231-0726
Fax: 925-372 -4244
Martinez Law Office Map

Subscribe to This Blog's Feed FindLaw Network